اما بالنسبة لكتاب الكافى فهو الان بيحقق من قبل عائلة الملا فى مدينة الاحساء
ولكن الاهم من استخراج المخطوطات وتحقيقها هو الاهتمام بما هو مطبوع فهناك الكثير من الكتب المطبوعة بحاجة الىتحقيق ودراسة بل واعادة صف مثل حاشية بن عابدين واصول السرخسى
جزاك الله خيرا على المعلومة القيمة حول الكافي.
بالنسبة لرد المحتار الذي طبع متأخرا بدمشق، ما رأي الأعضاء فيه؟ سمعتُ أنه لم يُزَد فيه إلا بتصحيح المتن! هل فيه تخريج للآثار أو شيء آخر؟ وفيه فقد ذمه أحد الإخوة في منتدى إنجليزي:
Sadly, this project is over-hyped, badly planned and terribly carried out.
It will be in a total of 22 or 23 volumes, with them taking a few years to produce each volume. They just finished volume 17.
I know those working on the project, have spent time with them and even given them Hanafi works that they didn't have.
They aren't adding anything extra to the book, it is just a glorified job of re-editing the book and making takhrij of some of nusus on it from the common important books.
These 20 years and hundreds of thousands of dollars could have been much better spent, if this project was properly planned and run accordingly.
The current edition of the book - in 17 volumes- contains many errors, which are due to be corrected in the second edition.
That should take a minimum of 5 more years, as they will need at least 4 more to complete the project, then at least one more to prepare the second edition. I expect it to probably take more like 8-10 years!
This is the result of paying workers for their time and not for the work they produce, as well as the fruit of a poorly-planned project...
دمتم بخير.